Learn
Learn

Data extraction tools, techniques, and trends for ELT success

Data extraction tools, techniques, and trends for ELT success

August 14, 2025
August 14, 2025
Data extraction tools, techniques, and trends for ELT success
From diverse data sources to strict compliance: Learn how modern data extraction tools tackle schema drift, uptime challenges, and governance requirements—at scale.

Today's data teams don't just pull from a single source. They sync product analytics from Mixpanel, customer records from Salesforce, and transaction data from Snowflake. This is often done at scale and in near real time.

Data extraction tools make this possible. They automate the connection, querying, and syncing of data from APIs, databases, files, and unstructured sources into central platforms like data lakes or data warehouses. They form the "E" (Extract) in the modern ELT (Extract, Load, Transform) paradigm.

But with hundreds of tools now claiming “easy extraction,” how do technical teams separate scalable, resilient platforms from brittle, high-maintenance connectors?

This article explores what data extraction tools actually do, how they fit into your ELT strategy, and which features matter most when building resilient, observable, and compliant data pipelines in 2025.

What is a data extraction tool?

A data extraction tool is the engine behind the first step in a data pipeline. It retrieves data from its original source — be it a transactional database, SaaS application API, cloud storage bucket, or legacy mainframe — and prepares it for the loading stage.

During the extraction process, these tools account for each source system's unique format, structure, and access protocol.

The importance of data extraction tools

Without a dedicated extraction tool, engineers have to write and maintain custom scripts for every data source. This manual approach is not only time-consuming but also incredibly fragile. According to a 2022 report by Wakefield Research, data engineers spend nearly half their workweek simply maintaining and fixing broken data pipelines.

Modern data extraction tools eliminate manual querying and insecure spreadsheet exports. They accomplish this using built-in connectors and scheduling frameworks that automate continuous data synchronization from dozens of sources.

By automating this critical first step, they ensure that data pipelines are reliable, timely, and not reliant on shadow IT.

An effective extraction strategy frees engineering teams from endless pipeline maintenance so they can focus on generating value from data for business intelligence, analytics, and machine learning models.

Types of data extraction

The proper extraction method depends on the data source, volume, velocity, and the downstream use case's latency requirements.

Full extraction

Full extraction means retrieving every record from the source system each time the pipeline executes.

While this approach is simple to implement and guarantees a complete data refresh, it becomes highly inefficient for large or frequently updated datasets, placing a significant load on source systems and consuming excessive network bandwidth. As a result, it is best suited for small, slow-changing dimension tables or initial data loads.

Incremental batch extraction

Incremental extraction syncs only new or changed records since the last pipeline run, usually by tracking a high-water mark such as a timestamp column (e.g., last_updated_at) or a sequential primary key. This approach is far more efficient than full extraction, cutting down on processing time and reducing load on source systems.

However, it does introduce some latency (updates might only occur hourly or daily), and it won’t automatically capture deletions without extra logic. Incremental extraction is best suited for structured data sourced from transactional databases or APIs when true real-time freshness isn’t critical.

Incremental stream extraction (Change Data Capture - CDC)

Change Data Capture (CDC) is a sophisticated technique that reads a database’s transaction log to capture row-level inserts, updates, and deletes in real time.

By tapping directly into the log, CDC delivers the freshest possible data with minimal latency and imposes very little load on the source system. It reliably records every modification, including deletions.

CDC is ideal for high-volume transactional environments, real-time analytics, fraud detection, and any operational use case that demands up-to-the-second data freshness.

The trade-off is that it can be more complex to configure and requires secure, low-level access to database logs.

For a deep dive into the mechanics and design principles of log-based CDC, see Martin Kleppmann’s authoritative overview.

Web scraping

This method involves programmatically parsing the HTML of web pages to extract data directly from the content. It is typically used as a last resort when a structured data source or a formal API is unavailable.

However, web scraping is notoriously brittle and high-maintenance, as pipelines can break with any minor change to a website's layout or structure. It also raises legal and ethical considerations regarding a website's terms of service.

Common challenges in data extraction

Building and scaling data extraction pipelines is a significant engineering challenge. Data teams must often navigate diverse, idiosyncratic, and unpredictable data sources.

API quirks & schema inconsistency

Every API has its own rules for pagination (offset-based, cursor-based), authentication (OAuth 2.0, API keys), and rate limiting.

SaaS vendors frequently update their APIs, introducing breaking changes or deprecating fields with little warning. For example, the APIs for social media platforms are notorious for their frequent updates and strict rate limits.

Manually coding around these inconsistencies for every source is a recipe for brittle pipelines.

Volume & velocity

High-volume sources can generate millions of records per hour, such as ad clickstream data from Google Ads, event streams from Kafka, or transaction logs from an e-commerce database. Naive full-sync pipelines quickly fail under this load.

A scalable extraction process requires incremental and log-based methods to handle massive data flows without overwhelming source systems.

Schema drift

Source schemas inevitably change over time. Product teams add new features, resulting in new tables or columns in the application database.

This evolution, known as schema drift, will break pipelines unless the extraction tool can handle it automatically. It must detect and propagate new columns and tables to the destination or, at a minimum, alert users to the change without failing the entire pipeline.

Unstructured inputs

A significant portion of enterprise customer data is stored in unstructured formats, such as invoices, handwritten texts, receipts, and PDFs.

Extracting this information requires specialized techniques like Optical Character Recognition (OCR) or Natural Language Processing (NLP). The quality and consistency of this extraction can vary widely depending on the document's formatting, making it a complex challenge to automate reliably.

Legacy systems

Many established enterprises rely on mainframes and on-premises applications that lack modern APIs.

Extracting data from these systems often requires using Java Database Connectivity (JDBC) drivers, querying databases directly, or parsing batch file exports (e.g., fixed-width or COBOL copybook files), adding a layer of legacy complexity to modern data integration efforts.

Security & compliance

Organizations must take a security-first approach to protect sensitive data, such as revenue, accounting, or employee information. For example, Fivetran and other automated data movement solutions use column masking to make certain sensitive column-level data inaccessible to unauthorized users.

Extraction tools must support end-to-end encryption (both in transit and at rest), PII redaction or masking, and data residency controls.

These and other compliance features and audit trails are critical for companies subject to stringent regulations like the EU's General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA).

Key features of a modern data extraction tool

To overcome these challenges, modern data extraction tools provide reliable, hands-off data pipelines that accelerate decision-making, lower operational costs, and free up engineering resources.

  • Connector coverage

The platform's value is directly tied to the breadth and depth of its connector library. It must support the full spectrum of an organization's data sources, including relational databases, NoSQL databases, SaaS application APIs, cloud storage, and event streams.

  • Automatic schema evolution

Source data models are not static; they constantly evolve as applications are updated. An enterprise-grade tool must automatically sense these structural modifications, such as new columns or tables, and replicate them in the destination.

This capability is essential for maintaining pipeline uptime and ensuring that data flow continues uninterrupted, freeing data teams from the constant, reactive cycle of manually repairing broken pipelines.

  • Efficient change data capture

A modern platform must provide sophisticated techniques for capturing only what has changed to process data at scale without overwhelming source systems.

The most robust method is log-based Change Data Capture (CDC), which reads the native database transaction log to identify inserts, updates, and deletes. This approach places a minimal load on production databases and dramatically lowers data latency, ensuring the destination is kept current in near-real-time.

  • Built-in fault tolerance and reliability

Production pipelines operate in an imperfect world of intermittent network failures and temporary API downtime. A reliable platform must, therefore, have built-in fault tolerance, including intelligent retry logic for transient errors and the ability to gracefully manage source API rate limits.

Crucially, this extends to guaranteeing idempotent execution, the ability to re-run a sync after a failure without creating duplicate records or losing data. Idempotency is a non-negotiable feature for protecting data integrity.

  • Observability and monitoring

End-to-end visibility into your pipelines is essential for any production environment. The platform should provide detailed dashboards, granular sync logs, data lineage tracing (e.g., via integration with OpenLineage), and automated failure alerts to give teams complete visibility into pipeline health and performance.

  • Enterprise-grade security

Security must be built in from the beginning, not tacked on later.

Key features include Role-Based Access Control (RBAC), end-to-end encryption using the latest standards, support for private networking (e.g., AWS PrivateLink), and features for column-level hashing or blocking to protect PII. The tool should hold certifications like SOC 2 Type II and comply with HIPAA.

  • Low-code/No-code configuration

Features like setup wizards, drag-and-drop functionality, and template libraries empower more team members to manage data movement, streamlining the overall data integration workflow.

Engineers and analysts should be able to configure and deploy a new data pipeline in under ten minutes, without writing or maintaining custom code. This approach frees up core engineering resources for other priorities.

In practice, these features allow data pipelines to scale as the business grows and meet strict governance rules, giving business intelligence and data science teams the trustworthy, analysis-ready data they need to work with.

Top data extraction tools

Choosing the right platform requires systematically reviewing your needs against the available tools. The market for data extraction tools generally falls into three categories: fully managed platforms, open-source alternatives, and specialized solutions.

Managed solutions

These services handle data pipelines' infrastructure, maintenance, and scalability, allowing teams to focus on using data rather than managing the underlying systems.
  • Fivetran: A fully managed, automated ELT platform with 700+ pre-built connectors. It excels at automated schema handling, log-based CDC, and enterprise-grade security, designed for teams prioritizing reliability and low operational overhead.
  • Stitch: A developer-friendly ELT service, now part of Talend, that offers basic transformation capabilities and over 130 integrations. It is often favored by teams looking for a simple, extensible tool for less complex pipelines.
  • Hevo is a real-time, no-code pipeline builder with reverse ETL functionality and a UI-first configuration experience aimed at business users and data analysts.
  • Talend cloud: A comprehensive data integration and governance platform for large enterprises. It often requires more specialized expertise to manage compared to more automated tools.
  • Matillion: A cloud-native ELT tool that focuses heavily on deep, in-warehouse data transformation capabilities, often used by teams with complex data modeling requirements.

Managed platforms offer significant advantages in terms of reliability and low maintenance, making them ideal for teams focused on accelerating time-to-value.

Open-source or self-hosted platforms

This category offers greater control and customization but requires teams to manage the software's deployment, maintenance, and scaling themselves.
  • Airbyte: A rapidly growing open-source platform known for its vast library of over 500 connectors and a Connector Development Kit (CDK) for building custom integrations. It offers both self-hosted and cloud-hosted options, but requires more engineering effort to manage and maintain than fully managed platforms.
  • Apache NiFi: A powerful, flow-based tool from the Apache Software Foundation for routing, transforming, and extracting data. Its visual, drag-and-drop interface is highly flexible but has a steep learning curve.
  • Singer: An open-source standard for writing custom extract (Taps) and load (Targets) scripts. It provides a framework but requires significant engineering work to operationalize into production-ready, reliable pipelines.

While these open-source tools provide maximum flexibility and control, some extraction tasks require even more specialized solutions.

Specialized tools

Some extraction challenges are so specific that they warrant dedicated tools designed for a single purpose, such as web scraping or document parsing.
  • Scrapy / Octoparse: Open-source and commercial tools, respectively, explicitly designed for scraping data from websites.
  • AWS textract / Nanonets: AI-driven cloud services for parsing and extracting structured data from documents, forms, and invoices.
  • Kafka Connect: A core component of the Apache Kafka ecosystem, providing a framework for building and running streaming data extractors and sinks for Kafka-based pipelines.

Ultimately, the right choice depends on a team's specific use cases, existing infrastructure, and the balance they wish to strike between engineering control and operational efficiency.

Trends shaping data extraction in 2025

Data extraction is evolving rapidly as automation, intelligence, and security become standard expectations.

AI-assisted connector building

The next frontier in connector development is AI assistance. Platforms are beginning to use LLMs to auto-generate connector configurations by parsing API documentation, suggest schema mappings, and even learn from extraction failures to improve resilience.

Streaming-first pipelines

As businesses demand real-time insights, traditional daily or hourly batch jobs give way to event-driven, streaming pipelines. Technologies like Change Data Capture, Flink, and Kafka are becoming mainstream for operational use cases that cannot tolerate data latency.

Built-in data observability

Connectors are no longer black boxes. Modern platforms emit detailed metrics, logs, and lineage metadata as a first-class feature.

This data can be integrated with observability tools like Monte Carlo and Datadog, or standards like OpenLineage, to automatically detect data quality issues (such as schema drift, data type changes, and runtime anomalies) before they affect downstream reports and dashboards.

Security by default

Security is a foundational requirement in an era of heightened privacy awareness and regulatory scrutiny.

Modern tools are designed with a "security by default" posture, shipping with native encryption, comprehensive audit logs, and pre-built compliance templates for regulations like SOC 2, HIPAA, and ISO 27001.

Embedded ELT (Connector-as-a-Service)

Leading ELT platforms are now being embedded directly into SaaS applications via partner APIs. This "Powered by Fivetran" model allows SaaS companies to offer robust, native integrations to their customers without having to build and maintain data pipeline infrastructure in-house.

Build resilient data platforms

Data extraction tools are no longer just about getting data out; they are about doing it continuously, securely, and scalably. Choosing a tool is a strategic infrastructure decision, not a simple purchase.

As data complexity continues to rise, platforms like Fivetran are becoming essential infrastructure for any company that aims to be truly data-driven.

Looking to streamline your ELT workflows and speed up insights?
[CTA_MODULE]

Start your 14-day free trial with Fivetran today!
Get started now
Topics
Share

Related posts

Data transformations: what’s the T in ELT?
Blog

Data transformations: what’s the T in ELT?

Read post
Why ELT is the future of data integration
Blog

Why ELT is the future of data integration

Read post
Why ELT will disrupt ETL
Blog

Why ELT will disrupt ETL

Read post
ETL vs ELT
Blog

ETL vs ELT

Read post
ETL process: from data to decisions
Blog

ETL process: from data to decisions

Read post
8 best ELT tools for enterprises (2023 guide)
Blog

8 best ELT tools for enterprises (2023 guide)

Read post
ETL vs ELT
Blog

ETL vs ELT

Read post
ETL process: from data to decisions
Blog

ETL process: from data to decisions

Read post
8 best ELT tools for enterprises (2023 guide)
Blog

8 best ELT tools for enterprises (2023 guide)

Read post

Start for free

Join the thousands of companies using Fivetran to centralize and transform their data.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.