Companies are collecting more data than ever before — from customer interactions and sales to social media. But raw data on its own isn’t very useful. It’s like having a library full of books in different languages without a translator. You need to organize and process that data to extract meaningful insights. Without the right tools, this task is herculean. 

ETL (Extract, Transform, Load) and ELT (Extract, Load, Transform) are the two primary methods data processing uses to handle data integration. Think of ETL as the traditional way, where you clean and transform your data before loading it into your storage.  

ELT is a newer approach and flips the script, loading raw data first and then transforming it as needed. Understanding their strengths and ideal use cases can help you choose the right approach for your business needs.

What is ETL (Extract, Transform, Load)?

ETL stands for Extract, Transform, Load. It's a well-known method for integrating data. The process starts with gathering data from various sources, then transforming it to fit the desired format and loading it into a storage system.  

Developed as a data processing method in the 1970s, ETL quickly became synonymous with data integration. Back then, technology had its limits — storage and computing power were expensive and scarce. ETL remedied this issue by transforming data before it was loaded, saving space and processing power. This method conserved valuable resources during a time when every byte and CPU cycle counted.

The ETL process involves three main steps:

1. Extract: Pull data from various sources such as databases, APIs and flat files. This step involves identifying the relevant data and properly gathering it for the next phase.
2. Transform: Convert the data into a format suitable for analysis. This process can include cleaning, aggregating and enriching the data.
3. Load: Transfer the transformed data into a target system, like a data warehouse, where you can access it for analysis.

To break this process down further, you first identify the data sources. Then, you scope out what the project needs in terms of data analysis. Next, you define the data model or schema you’ll use. After that, you build the pipeline and use the data for analytics and insights.

Common use cases and scenarios for ETL

ETL is particularly useful when dealing with structured data that you’ll process and analyze regularly. It's often used in scenarios like:

• Data warehousing: Consolidating data from different sources into a centralized warehouse for reporting and analysis.  
• Business intelligence: Transforming raw data into meaningful insights through dashboards and reports.  
• Data migration: Moving data from old systems to new ones during upgrades or consolidations. This process maintains data consistency and integrity across different platforms.
• Data integration: Combining data from various sources to provide a unified view. This process is invaluable in CRM software, where integrated data improves the understanding of customer behavior.
• Compliance reporting: Ensuring that data is accurately processed and formatted to meet regulatory requirements. ETL processes help generate reliable and timely compliance reports.

Organizations that leverage ETL tools to efficiently manage their data produce information that is clean, accurate and ready for analysis. In turn, this high-quality data boosts confidence in decision-making.

Benefits and limitations of using ETL

ETL (Extract, Transform, Load) remains a common method for data integration. However, its advantages have diminished over time and it presents several challenges. The primary benefits that ETL users cite include:

• Efficiency: By transforming data before loading, ETL decreases the volume of data stored in the warehouse, preserving resources throughout the entire workflow. This benefit reduces storage and processing requirements, leading to more efficient data handling.
• Consistency: ETL standardizes your data before loading it into the target system, ensuring uniformity and reliability for analysis.
• Control: ETL lets you manipulate and transform data extensively to fit your specific needs, giving you a lot of control over how you process and use your data.

In an ETL process, you extract and transform data before loading it into a destination. This close linkage was necessary when storage, computation and bandwidth were extremely scarce. As a result of this arrangement, ETL retains some limitations:

• Complexity: Building and maintaining ETL pipelines can be labor-intensive and complex, especially with changing data sources and requirements. Data pipelines not only extract data, they also perform sophisticated transformations tailored to the specific analytics needs of the end users. This process often requires a significant amount of custom code.
• Scalability: Scaling ETL processes can be challenging as data volumes grow. Transformations dictated by the specific needs of analysts mean every ETL pipeline is a complicated, custom-built solution. The complex nature of these pipelines makes scaling difficult, particularly when adding new data sources and models.
• Maintenance: ETL systems need frequent updates to manage changes in data sources and transformation logic. Changes in data schemas often disrupt the pipeline, requiring significant revisions to the ETL code. Additionally, since data extraction and transformation are interdependent, interruptions in transformation can halt data loading, leading to downtime.

ETL was developed to manage data under past constraints of expensive and scarce resources. While it offers efficiency, consistency and control, the conditions that necessitated its design have dramatically changed. Storage costs have plummeted and data volumes have surged, challenging the traditional ETL approach with its complex, labor-intensive maintenance and difficulty scaling in high-volume environments. 

What is ELT (Extract, Load, Transform)?

ELT stands for Extract, Load, Transform. This method flips the traditional ETL process on its head. Instead of transforming data before loading it into a storage system, ELT involves loading raw data directly into the destination and then transforming it. 

Key components and steps in the ELT process

The ELT process uncouples the extraction and transformation processes, streamlining the data workflow. It involves three main steps:

1. Extract: Pull data from various sources like databases, APIs and flat files. This step efficiently and effectively collects all relevant data from its origins.
2. Load: Immediately load this raw data into a target system, such as a data warehouse. This rapid loading makes data available for further processing.
3. Transform: Once the data is loaded, transform it into the desired format for analysis. This process can include cleaning, aggregating and enriching the data.

In ELT, the workflow cycle is shorter, which enhances the speed of data processing. Here’s how the operational tasks break down:

Identify data sources

Pinpoint where the data will be gathered, such as databases, spreadsheets, or online services to achieve a comprehensive collection of data.

Automate extraction and loading

Establish automated systems that reliably transfer data from its sources to the storage or analysis platforms without manual intervention.

Define analytical needs

Clarify the goals of the data project, which might include identifying key performance indicators (KPIs) or specific business questions to answer.

Build transformations

Create data models and transformations that reformat, clean and structure the raw data into a usable format aligned with your analytical needs. 

Analyze and extract insights

Perform analyses to uncover patterns, trends and insights, which are then compiled into reports or dashboards for strategic decision-making.

‍

The ELT workflow is both simpler and more customizable than the ETL process. As a result, it’s ideal for analysts who require the flexibility to create tailored data transformations on demand, without the need for reconstructing the entire data pipeline.

The rise of ELT with modern data warehouses

ELT has gained popularity with modern, cloud-based data warehouses like Snowflake, BigQuery and Redshift, which offer immense storage and computing power. Being in the cloud, you can load raw data first and transform it as needed. This approach has become more viable due to the decreased costs of storage and computation afforded by cloud technology.  Here are some key advantages that illustrate why ELT is well-suited for modern cloud-based data architectures.

• Scalability: Unlike traditional ETL, which requires time-consuming hardware installations for scaling, ELT platforms quickly adjust to changing data needs. Automated systems in cloud data warehouses scale operations up or down within minutes, eliminating the need to adjust physical hardware.
• Transformation process: ELT platforms perform data transformations directly within the data warehouse using SQL. This process simplifies transformation and shifts data integration to a more analyst-driven activity.
• Use of data lakes: ELT can use data lakes for storing large-scale unstructured data, managed by distributed NoSQL systems or big data platforms. These storage solutions further improve the flexibility and scalability of data management.

The shift towards ELT in data warehouses represents a significant move towards more dynamic and analyst-friendly data handling, allowing businesses to respond to evolving data requirements.

Common use cases and scenarios for ELT

ELT really shines when it comes to managing massive volumes of unstructured or semi-structured data. Few methods handle data complexity as efficiently. Its ability to process and transform data directly within robust cloud-based data warehouses makes it the preferred method in several challenging scenarios, including:

• Big data processing: ELT easily manages vast amounts of raw data that require analysis. It allows for the tailoring and execution of transformations post-loading, which enhances the analysis and use of large datasets.

• Real-time analytics: ELT supports live data streams and real-time data processing. It provides quicker access to and manipulation of real-time data, essential for industries that depend on timely analytics for decision-making.
• Data lakes: Massive amounts of raw data are stored in data lakes and can be transformed as required. This method offers greater flexibility in data usage and manipulation, accommodating diverse analytical needs without preprocessing.

• Machine learning: ELT’s flexibility benefits raw data prepared for training machine learning models. Data scientists can efficiently experiment with various transformations post-loading.

Companies that adopt ELT streamline their data processes and improve data accessibility. As a result, their data teams can fully leverage their data to drive insight generation and foster innovation.

Benefits of using ELT

ELT offers several advantages that make it a superior choice for modern data management needs:

• Flexibility: Allows for on-the-fly transformations, making it easier to adapt to changing analytical needs. This flexibility means data teams can respond quicker to business changes without extensive pipeline reconfigurations.
• Scalability: Easily scales with cloud resources, accommodating growing data volumes. As data needs expand, ELT seamlessly integrates additional resources without performance degradation.
• Efficiency: Reduces the initial complexity of data pipelines by delaying data transformations until after loading. This approach speeds up data ingestion and optimizes computer resource usage. 
• Reduced failure rates: Decoupling extraction and transformation minimizes the impact of transformation errors on data loading. It enhances overall system reliability by isolating errors, which can be corrected without affecting the entire pipeline.

Over the past few years, companies across various industries have transitioned from ETL to ELT to capitalize on these benefits. ELT separates the extraction and transformation processes, which shields the extraction and loading phases from the frequent changes in upstream schemas and downstream data models. This separation leads to a simpler, more robust approach to data integration, reducing the chances of system failures and streamlining operations.

ETL vs ELT: Side-by-side comparison

A side-by-side comparison of ELT versus ETL can help potential users better understand their distinct capabilities:

‍

ETL (Extract, Transform, Load)

ELT (Extract, Load, Transform)

Data handling

Processes and filters data before loading

Loads data first, then processes it

Infrastructure dependency

Can operate both on-premise and in the cloud

Primarily optimized for cloud environments

Performance

Can be slower due to upfront data transformation

Generally faster as data loads directly

Flexibility

Requires predefined data models and transformations

More flexible, allowing ad-hoc queries and transformations

Scalability

Scalability can be challenging due to fixed hardware constraints

Highly scalable, especially with cloud resources

Maintenance

High maintenance due to complex transformations pre-load

Lower maintenance with transformations in database

Cost efficiency

Requires more computing power upfront, potentially increasing costs

More cost-effective in long term with less intensive compute during loading

Accessibility

Requires technical expertise, often IT-driven

More accessible to non-technical users with SQL skills

Security

Security can be tightly controlled, suitable for sensitive data

Requires robust cloud security, but generally secure

Use case suitability

Ideal for stable, well-understood data environments

Best for dynamic environments with evolving data needs

Contextual considerations

ELT is renowned for its flexibility, speed and cost-effectiveness, which makes it an increasingly popular choice in most data integration scenarios. It excels in environments that require rapid data handling, thanks to its ability to adapt on the fly and efficiently manage huge datasets. These capabilities are significantly bolstered by the advanced features of cloud technology.

In scenarios where data models don't change much and security needs are top priority, ETL has traditionally been the go-to because it handles data transformations before loading. This is often the case in large enterprises with fixed data systems. The advancing security features of cloud-based data warehouses are closing this gap, making ELT a preferred option.

Many organizations find a hybrid approach beneficial. They leverage ELT for its superior scalability and efficiency with third-party SaaS products, while they gradually shift away from ETL for sensitive or proprietary data. Improvements in cloud security measures are accelerating this shift.

The move towards ELT is helping organizations streamline operations and cut costs while still meeting their operational and security needs. This shift helps companies turn data into actionable insights. That's why ELT is quickly becoming a top choice in data integration strategies.

Simple solutions for complex data pipelines

Exploring data pipelines might seem overwhelming, but it doesn't have to be. Keeping things simple can make a huge difference when you're dealing with complex data flows. Let's look at some practical ways to streamline these processes and make them more manageable. 

H3: Practical strategies and tools for implementing ETL and ELT

To optimize your data management workflows for better efficiency and accuracy, apply these straightforward strategies:

• Automate where you can: Manual processes are time-consuming and prone to error. Automation tools like Apache NiFi or AWS Glue can streamline your data workflows so that your data is processed efficiently and accurately. These tools handle everything from data ingestion to transformation, reducing the workload on your team and freeing up time for more strategic tasks.
• Leverage cloud services: Cloud platforms like Google BigQuery and Snowflake offer scalable solutions for data storage and processing. They handle large volumes of data and complex queries with ease without the overhead of managing physical servers. Additionally, these cloud services also integrate seamlessly with various data sources, simplifying your pipeline architecture.
• Focus on data quality: Poor data quality can derail even the best-designed pipelines. To combat this roadblock, actively implement robust data validation and cleansing processes. Tools like dbt (data build tool) can help maintain data integrity by enabling version control, testing and documentation. This process keeps your data reliable and useful throughout its lifecycle.

Putting these strategies into play will boost the reliability and usefulness of your entire data system. This groundwork paves the way for gaining deeper insights and smarter decision-making down the line.

Try ELT for free

Both ETL and ELT are robust data integration processes, each suited for specific scenarios. For most organizations today, however, ELT stands out as the superior choice. Looking for quicker and easier access to your business and customer data? ELT is your solution.

ELT streamlines processes by automating tasks, facilitating third-party integrations and enabling outsourcing. These features save time and reduce costs, empowering analysts to extract meaningful insights more efficiently.

For those looking to implement secure, cloud-based data pipelines across various industries, Fivetran is an ideal platform. It allows you to consolidate data from diverse databases and applications into one central hub.

Still on the fence? Take advantage of the Fivetran Free Plan — which now includes dbt core-compatible data models — and experience the benefits of ELT at no cost.

‍